How To Make A Paper Mache Pumpkin Head Costume

Posted in Crafts
Handmade orange and white paper mache pumpkin heads displayed as moody Halloween decor on a rustic wood console.
How To Make A Paper Mache Pumpkin Head Costume

Looking for a Halloween costume that’s creative, inexpensive, and guaranteed to get a few laughs? I made these oversized paper mache pumpkin heads using newspaper, trash bags, twine, and paint. They’re lightweight enough to wear as a DIY pumpkin head costume, but they can also be reused as spooky Halloween porch decor. I’ll show you exactly how I shaped, covered, carved, and painted them—plus share a few of our favorite homemade costumes at the end.

This post has been updated in September 2026 with clearer instructions, helpful costume tips, and additional information to make this paper mache pumpkin head easier to create and wear.

* As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases and through other companies as well. You will not be charged extra when you purchase through these affiliate links, but any income I make helps me create more amazing DIY projects to share with you! To see my full disclaimer, click here!


The Story Behind Our DIY Pumpkin Head Costumes

For seven years, we attended a Halloween costume party hosted by dear friends in their huge shop building. They went all out with decorations, disco lights, and a DJ—and everyone arrived wearing a costume they had created themselves.

And I’ll tell you right now, this wasn’t one of those parties where everyone stands around staring at each other like an awkward high school dance. These people took their costumes seriously! They were my kind of people.

That year, I decided oversized paper mache pumpkin heads would make the perfect costume for the two of us. It was a slightly crazy idea, but thankfully, my hubby has learned to go along with my DIY adventures.


Supplies for a Paper Mache Pumpkin Head

  • Newspaper torn into strips
  • Newspaper or tissue paper for stuffing
  • Kitchen trash bag or plastic grocery bag
  • Twine or sturdy string
  • Masking tape or painter’s tape
  • Wood glue and water, mixed in equal parts
  • Bowl for mixing
  • Paintbrush
  • Scissors
  • Utility knife
  • White, orange, brown, and black craft paint
  • Fine-mist spray bottle filled with water
  • Disposable gloves and a table covering, optional

Safety note: An adult should handle the utility knife when cutting the opening and facial features. When wearing the finished pumpkin head, make sure the eye openings provide clear visibility, and the bottom opening allows plenty of airflow.


Step 1: Choose the Size of Your Pumpkin Head

This isn’t the traditional balloon-and-paste method for making paper mache. I didn’t have a large balloon or paper mache paste on hand, so I made DO with what I already had—and that’s often when the most creative ideas happen.

Before choosing a bag, measure around the widest part of your head. The finished opening must be large enough to slide comfortably over your head, and the pumpkin needs enough space inside for airflow.

I used a kitchen trash bag to make the larger pumpkin head for my hubby and a plastic grocery bag for my smaller one. Remember that the bag determines the overall size and shape of your finished pumpkin.

For a smoother, rounder pumpkin, you can use a large balloon or an inflatable beach ball as the form. I wanted mine to have a wonderfully imperfect, handmade look, so the crumpled newspaper method worked perfectly.

what to do with old newspapers

Newspaper tip: Ask your local newspaper office whether they have outdated or extra copies available. You may be able to get all the paper you need for free.

What To Do With Old Newspapers

Step 2: Stuff and Shape the Bag

Crumple full sheets of newspaper into loose balls and place them inside the bag one at a time. You can also use tissue paper or other lightweight packing paper.

Continue filling the bag until it holds a rounded pumpkin shape, but don’t pack it too tightly. Leaving a little movement inside will make it easier to adjust the shape and create the pumpkin ridges in the next step.

Check the size against your head before closing the bag. The form should be noticeably wider than your head so the finished pumpkin shell will fit comfortably.

If you’re using a grocery bag with handles, cut each handle in half to create four ends. Pull the ends together and tie them securely at the top. For a trash bag without handles, gather the opening and secure it with twine or masking tape.

how to make a paper mache pumpkin from old newspapers

Step 3: Create the Pumpkin Ridges With Twine

Cut four long pieces of twine, making each one long enough to wrap completely around the stuffed bag with extra length for tying.

Lay the first piece of twine on your work surface and center the stuffed bag on top of it. Bring both ends up around the bag and tie them securely at the top. Gently tighten the twine until it creates a defined groove in the pumpkin.

Repeat with the remaining pieces, spacing them evenly around the bag. Adjust the twine as needed until the pumpkin has balanced, natural-looking sections. Add more pieces if you want narrower ridges.

Trim away the excess twine, then secure the gathered bag and tied ends at the top with masking tape or painter’s tape.

I was having so much fun shaping the pumpkin that I forgot to photograph this part. Sometimes I get a little carried away once a DIY idea starts working!

DIY Pumpkin

Step 4: Apply the Paper Mache Layers

Now comes the messy part!

To create a strong paper mache shell, mix equal parts wood glue and water in a bowl. Stir until the mixture is smooth and completely combined. Mod Podge can also be used as an alternative.

Tear the newspaper into strips rather than cutting it. The soft, torn edges overlap and blend more smoothly than straight-cut edges.

Working with one strip at a time, coat the newspaper with the glue mixture and smooth it over the stuffed bag. Carefully press the paper into the twine’s grooves so the pumpkin ridges remain visible. A paintbrush works well, but I eventually used my hands—which was much easier and a whole lot messier.

Overlap the edges of the strips until the entire form is covered. Allow the first layer to dry completely before adding another.

Overlap the edges of the strips until the entire form is covered. Allow the first layer to dry completely before adding another.

How To Make A Paper Mache Pumpkin

How Many Paper Mache Layers Are Needed?

I applied four layers to make my pumpkin head strong enough to hold its shape after removing the stuffing. Allow each layer to dry completely before adding the next one. Depending on the humidity and thickness of the paper, drying may take overnight or longer.

Make sure the shell feels completely firm and dry before cutting into it. Any damp areas inside could weaken the finished pumpkin or lead to mildew.

Overlap the edges of the strips until the entire form is covered. Allow the first layer to dry completely before adding another.

DIY paper mache pumpkin

Step 5: Make and Attach the Pumpkin Stem

To make the pumpkin stem, spread a generous amount of the glue mixture over one side of a sheet of newspaper.

Grab the dry side of the paper near the center and begin twisting it into a stem shape. Squeeze and shape the glued paper as you twist, leaving the bottom wider than the top. Bend the stem slightly if you want it to have a more natural, whimsical appearance.

Tear or separate several small sections around the bottom of the stem and twist them outward. These extensions create a wider base and give the stem more surface area for attaching to the pumpkin.

Brush additional glue onto the top of the pumpkin, position the stem, and press the extended pieces firmly against the shell. Cover the base with a few small strips of paper mache to blend it into the pumpkin and make the attachment stronger.

Allow the stem and surrounding paper mache to dry completely before moving to the cutting and painting steps.

DIY Pumpkin Stems

Step 6: Cut the Opening and Pumpkin Face

Once the paper mache shell is completely dry and firm, turn the pumpkin upside down. Draw a circle on the bottom that is slightly smaller than you think you’ll need. It’s easier to enlarge the opening gradually than to repair one that was cut too big.

Place the pumpkin on a stable work surface and carefully cut along the line with a sharp utility knife. Remove the cut section, then pull out all the newspaper stuffing and loose material from inside the shell.

Test the opening and carefully trim it until the pumpkin slides comfortably over your head. Smooth or cover any rough cut edges with masking tape so they don’t scratch your neck or catch on clothing.

Next, lightly draw the eyes and mouth with a pencil. Cut out the facial features, making the eye openings large enough to provide clear visibility. The mouth opening can provide additional airflow while the pumpkin is being worn.

I left the twine inside because it helped support the shape, but you can remove any loose pieces that interfere with comfort or visibility.

Wearable costume tip: Try on the pumpkin head in a well-lit, open area before wearing it to an event. Make sure you can see clearly, breathe comfortably, and remove it quickly without assistance. Never wear it while driving or near candles, open flames, or other sources of heat.

Paper Mache Pumpkin Head

Step 7: Paint the Paper Mache Pumpkin Head

 Once the shell is completely dry and the openings have been cut, it’s time to give the pumpkin head some personality.

I used orange and white paint for the main colors, then layered in brown and black to create an aged, slightly spooky finish. You can use any craft, chalk-style, or leftover water-based paint you already have.

Apply the orange or white base coat first. While the paint is still slightly wet, add small amounts of brown and black around the ridges, stem, facial features, and other areas where natural shadows would appear.

Lightly mist the painted surface with water and blend the darker colors with a paintbrush. Work in small sections so you can soften the colors before they dry. Add more paint gradually—it’s much easier to deepen the finish than to remove too much dark paint.

Allow the pumpkin head to dry completely before wearing it. If desired, paint the cut edges around the eyes and mouth black to make the facial features appear deeper and more dramatic.

Paper Mache Pumpkins

Optional shortcut: You can use spray paint for the base coat. Apply it outdoors or in a properly ventilated area and follow the manufacturer’s safety and drying instructions.

Painting an orange paper mache pumpkin head made from newspaper for a DIY Halloween costume.

Our Finished DIY Pumpkin Head Costumes

I have the best hubby in the world. He tolerates my wild DIY ideas—even when I can tell he isn’t completely on board. Happy wife, happy life! He gets me.

Our finished paper mache pumpkin heads turned out even better than I imagined. They were lightweight, easy to remove, and wonderfully creepy without being too scary—the perfect combination for a night of Halloween fun.

Of course, we had to do a pumpkin-head photo shoot in front of the barn. I set up the camera, lights, and tripod while the mules watched us between bites of hay. From the looks on their faces, you would have thought they were watching their own private horror movie.

I briefly considered becoming the headless horsewoman, but all I have are mules. Close enough, right? 🙂

Pumpkin Head Photo Shoot

Of course, we had to do a pumpkin-head photo shoot in front of the barn. I set up the camera, lights, and tripod while the mules watched us between bites of hay. From the looks on their faces, you would have thought they were watching their own private horror movie.

Pumpkin Head Photo Shoot

More of Our Homemade Halloween Costumes

The pumpkin heads weren’t our first homemade Halloween costumes. Over the years, my hubby and I have dressed up as everything from Shrek and Fiona to a pair of very yellow Minions.

Our wedding anniversary is October 27, so dressing up together has become a fun way to celebrate. Yes, that really was my wedding dress—and yes, he let me paint him green. Now that’s love!

Shrek and Fiona Halloween Costume

We also love the minions! We may be a little older than the average trick-or-treater, but I’m convinced Halloween costumes are even more fun when you’re grown.

DIY Minions Costume


Use Your Paper Mache Pumpkin Heads as Halloween Decor

These pumpkin heads were originally made as costumes, but I couldn’t pack them away after only one night of fun. I’ve also used them as Halloween decor around our barn, where their crooked smiles and imperfect painted finishes fit right in.

Set them on a covered porch, tuck them into a rustic fall display, or place them near the front door to greet Halloween visitors. You could also add battery-operated lights inside to make their carved faces glow after dark.

Since paper mache isn’t weatherproof, keep the pumpkins in a dry, protected area and bring them inside if rain is expected. Always use flameless, battery-operated lights—never candles or an open flame.

I love a DIY project that can pull double duty. One night they’re part of our costumes, and the next they’re sitting at the barn looking like they’ve lived there all their lives.

Orange and white paper mache pumpkin heads displayed with creamy mums and real pumpkins in front of a rustic barn gate.


A Pumpkin Head Costume You Can Reuse

I totally LOVE them!

Two handmade paper mache pumpkin heads displayed on a rustic wood console as moody indoor Halloween decor.

I hope this tutorial inspires you to turn a few simple supplies into your own DIY pumpkin head costume. Make it spooky, silly, or wonderfully imperfect—that’s the best part of creating something yourself.

Would you wear a giant pumpkin head to a Halloween party, or would you use it as decor instead? Let me know in the comments.

Don’t forget to save this project to Pinterest so you can find it when costume season rolls around.

Until the next project… xo, Do


More DIY Fall and Halloween Projects

If you enjoyed making this paper mache pumpkin head, here are a few more creative projects to help you decorate for fall and Halloween.

Share

10 Comments

  1. Omgoodness, I love this project, Do! The image of you and your hubby in the barn with your pumpkin heads literally gave me a big smile!! Happy belated anniversary, and I’m sure your costumes will steal the show!

  2. Ohhh, I MORE than enjoyed this fun tutorial Do, it gave me my morning laugh… LOVE IT! That first pic collage of you wearing the paper mache head – priceless! ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿคฃ๐ŸŽƒ You and your hubby make such a cute couple whether you’re green, yellow or pumpkinheads! ๐Ÿ’™ Great tutorial, thanks for sharing! XOXO

  3. I would love to see pictures of Jack and Dianne. It seems like it has been a long time since you posted pictures.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×